Thursday Boots Review: 6 Pros and 2 Complaints

In this Thursday Boots Review, we’ll share everything we found after months of wearing them.

Spoiler:

Thursday Boots are worth buying because they feel comfy and last long. They use real leather, which is why they look great with jeans or dress pants. Many people love them for everyday wear because these boots feel good right out of the box.

But Thursday Boots are not perfect, and there are 2 complaints you need to know before buying.

Also, we’ll tell you exactly how they compare to brands like Red Wing and Doc Martens.

Keep reading!

Key Takeaways

• Thursday Boots are made with full-grain leather and Goodyear welt construction.

• They’re comfortable from day one.

• You can dress them up or down, as they work with almost anything.

• Prices are under $200, which is wild for the quality.

• They offer half-sizes and wide fits for better sizing.

• Some pairs may have small flaws like glue marks or loose stitching.

• They’re made in Mexico, in a factory known for premium leatherwork.

Thursday Boots Review Table

Thursday Boots Review: Are They Worth the Hype?

Thursday Boots are 100% worth it for most people. They use top-tier materials like full-grain leather and Goodyear welt construction, making them durable and stylish. They’re also surprisingly comfy right out of the box, which isn’t common for boots.

We’ve worn Thursday boots for months, and here’s why we think they’re one of the best boot brands today:

Goodyear Welt Construction

Goodyear welt construction means Thursday boots are built to last. This technique is one of the gold standards in quality bootmaking. It creates a strong, water-resistant seal between the sole and upper, and it makes the boots easy to resole when they eventually wear down.

Most high-end boots use this method because it adds years to a boot’s life.

When we picked up our first pair of Thursday Boots, the solid construction was the first thing we noticed. You can actually feel the difference when you hold them.

And here’s what we love most: the ability to resole them. One of us had a pair of Captains for two years. When the sole wore down, a local cobbler put on a new one easily. That boot is still going strong.

Most cheap boots just end up in the trash after that kind of wear. So if you're thinking long-term, this feature alone makes the price worth it.

If comfort is a priority for you, here are some of the most comfortable work boots you should try.

High-Quality Leather

Thursday Boots use full-grain leather, which is the highest quality part of the hide. They get this leather from top tanneries like Horween in the US and Lefarc in Mexico.

When we first took our pair out of the box, the leather had this deep, rich look. It didn’t feel stiff like some boots. It was soft, with a slightly oily touch, which helps protect it from the elements.

Another bonus? The leather is surprisingly light. Some rugged boots feel like bricks, but Thursday gets the balance just right. That makes them perfect for city life, where you're walking more. At the same time, they're tough enough for weekend getaways in the woods.

Comfortable Out of the Box

Thanks to their Poron insoles and cork-bed midsoles, Thursday boots feel good right from day one. And they only get better as you wear them.

We remember walking in them the first day and expecting pain. But it never came. The Poron insole works like memory foam. It shapes to your foot over time, but gives cushion right away.

Stylish & Versatile Designs

Thursday Boots look good with almost anything. They’ve nailed the middle ground between rugged and refined. You can wear them with jeans or with dress pants, and they just work.

Our go-to is the Captain boot in brown. It looks sharp with dark jeans and a flannel, but we’ve also worn it with chinos and a button-up.

They also offer clean color choices, like black, brown, tobacco, and more. No weird shades that make it hard to match your outfit. That’s something we’ve always appreciated.

If you like the style of Thursday Boots, you might also be curious: Are cowboy boots actually comfortable?

Affordable Pricing

Thursday Boots give you a lot of premium features for under $200. You usually only see all that in boots that cost three hundred or more.

We also like that Thursday doesn’t play sales games. They don’t pretend to offer fake discounts all year. The price is fair and stays that way. You just get what you pay for, and it’s always worth it.

Wide Size Options

Finding boots that fit well isn’t easy for everyone. But Thursday makes it easier by offering a wide range of sizes. They have half sizes and different width options, so more people can get a proper fit.

We followed the sizing guide on their site and ordered what they recommended. And it worked. The boots hugged the foot without squeezing.

Oil and Slip-Resistant Soles

Thursday boots are made for real life, including:

• Slippery sidewalks
• Rainy days
• The kind of places where you don’t want to lose your footing.

Thursday uses outsoles that grip well, even in wet or slick spots.

We’ve walked in these boots during heavy rain and even through muddy parks. We never felt like we were going to slip. The traction is solid, but the sole doesn’t feel chunky or heavy.

They also absorb some of the shock when you walk. That means your knees and feet don’t take as much of a beating when you’re on your feet all day.

So if you want boots that help you stay steady, these are a great choice.

2 Common Issues Reported With Thursday Boots

Most people love their Thursday Boots, but there are a few complaints worth knowing. Some buyers have received pairs with minor flaws like glue spots or stitching that wasn’t perfect. Others say the boots don’t offer enough arch support for long days on their feet.

Quality Control Inconsistencies

Some customers have reported that the quality of Thursday Boots can vary. While most pairs arrive looking perfect, a few show glue marks, crooked stitching, or soles that separate earlier than expected.

Online reviews show the same pattern. Most people get solid, well-built boots. But now and then, someone posts pictures of stitching that isn’t straight.

It’s also worth noting that these boots are made in large batches. That means small slip-ups can happen.

Limited Arch Support

Thursday Boots feel great underfoot thanks to the Poron insoles and cork midsoles. But for people who need serious arch support, they might fall short. If you have high arches, you might feel the need for extra structure.

To be clear, these boots aren’t uncomfortable. They just don’t give that structured arch hold that some people need. And honestly, a lot of fashion boots skip that, too. So Thursday isn’t alone here.

Thursday Boots vs Other Brands (Comparison)

Thursday Boots are known for offering premium features at a price that’s easier on the wallet. They’re sleek and comfortable enough for daily wear. But how do they compare to other popular boot brands? Here's a side-by-side look:

Are Thursday Boots Uncomfortable?

No, Thursday Boots are not uncomfortable. In fact, they’re some of the most comfortable boots we’ve worn right out of the box. They use soft insoles made of Poron and a cork midsole that molds to your feet over time. This combo makes them feel cushioned and supportive from day one.

When we wore them on a full weekend trip, we didn’t feel any foot pain or blistering. That’s pretty rare with boots, especially leather ones.

That said, they don’t offer heavy arch support.

Is Thursday Boots a Luxury Brand?

Thursday Boots are not a luxury brand in the traditional sense. They don’t charge luxury prices, and they don’t market themselves that way. But they do offer a lot of luxury-level features, like:

• Full-grain leather
• Goodyear welt construction
• Timeless designs.

Are Thursday Boots Better Than Doc Martens?

Thursday Boots are better than Doc Martens. They’re made with stronger materials and offer better construction. Plus, they last longer. Doc Martens are known for their iconic style and comfort, but when it comes to build and leather quality, Thursday wins.

Let’s start with the leather: Thursday uses full-grain leather, which is the best cut you can get. It’s thick, tough, and ages really well. Doc Martens mostly use corrected grain or synthetic leather on their regular models. It doesn’t hold up the same way over time.

Thursday Boots also uses Goodyear welt construction. That’s a method used in premium boots that lets you resole them easily and gives better water resistance. Doc Martens also uses a form of welt, but it’s not the same level of durability. Their soles are glued and heat-sealed, not stitched like Thursdays.

We’ve worn both brands. Doc Martens are comfy right away, especially with their air-cushioned soles. But they can wear down faster, and once the sole goes, that’s it. Thursday gives you comfort plus long life.

Are Thursday Boots Made of Real Leather?

Yes, Thursday Boots are made of real leather. They use full-grain leather, which is the highest quality part of the hide. This is the same leather used in high-end boots that cost double or even triple the price.

Full-grain leather is durable and looks better as it ages. It holds up to rain, scratches, and everyday wear. Over time, it forms a natural patina that gives your boots a unique look. That’s something cheap leather or fake leather can’t do.

Where Are Thursday Boots Made?

Thursday Boots are designed in New York City, but they’re made in Mexico. They use factories in León, a city known for its world-class leatherwork. This is where a lot of top boot brands also manufacture their products.

Some people might worry about boots not being made in the USA, but we’ve been really impressed with the quality. The team at Thursday works directly with these factories to keep a close eye on every step.

Thursday also sources leather from both Mexico and the United States. For example, they work with Horween in Chicago and Lefarc in León. So even if the boots are assembled in Mexico, the materials are still top-tier.

In addition to Thursday boots, we also tested other shoes and sneakers at the same time. To know more, check out these reviews, too:

Final Thoughts

After wearing Thursday Boots day in and day out, we can say they really are worth buying. Here’s why:

• You’re getting real, full-grain leather that looks better over time.

• They’re super wearable and comfortable right out of the box.

• The price is low for the kind of build you’re getting.

• Sizing is better than most, thanks to half and wide options.

However, there are a few small issues, but none that would stop us from buying again.